In short
Many materials do not simply get weaker when diluted: they change character. Indole is fecal and animalic when strong and becomes floral, like white flowers, when very dilute. Phenylacetic acid moves from sharp and urine-like to honeyed. Damascones change from heavy and jammy to fresh rose and apple. In this exercise you smell three such materials across a dilution ladder and describe what changes, which teaches you why one dilution is never the whole truth about a material.
What you will learn
- Smell one material across a dilution ladder
- Describe changes in character, not only in strength
- Choose the right dilution for evaluating a material
Before this lesson: Find Your Own Odor Thresholds
Strength is not the only variable
Concentration changes which receptors respond and how strongly, and the brain's interpretation can change with it. The result is that the same molecule can read as two different smells at different strengths. That is why perfumers evaluate potent materials at several dilutions, and why the 10% smelling convention is a starting point rather than a rule. Thresholds were the subject of Find Your Own Odor Thresholds; this exercise looks above the threshold, at character. The reference article is odor threshold in perfumery.
Materials to use
| Material | Often described strong | Often described dilute |
|---|---|---|
| Indole | Fecal, animalic, mothball | Floral, white flower, jasmine-like |
| Phenylacetic acid | Sharp, sweaty, urine-like | Honey, sweet, waxy |
| beta-Damascone | Heavy, jammy, tobacco-plum | Fresh rose, apple, fruity |
The damascones are introduced in damascones in perfumery.
Making the ladder
Make each step from the one above, by weight: 1 g of material and 9 g of solvent for 10%; 1 g of the 10% and 9 g of solvent for 1%; and so on to 0.01%. Weighing 1 g at each step keeps the ladder accurate on an ordinary balance; the method is explained in working with trace materials. Use a low-odor solvent such as DPG or perfumer's ethanol, and label every bottle. Indole and phenylacetic acid are solids at room temperature: make sure the first step has dissolved completely, warming it gently if needed, before you take 1 g from it for the next.
Smelling the ladder
Smell from the weakest to the strongest, so the strong samples do not tire your nose before you reach the faint ones. Dip a fresh strip for each, wait for any ethanol to leave, and smell. Describe each with two or three words before you look at the table above — the table is there for comparison afterwards.
Practical exercise: Exercise: three materials, four strengths
- Make a four-step ladder (10%, 1%, 0.1%, 0.01%) for each of the three materials.
- Smell each ladder from weakest to strongest, resting between materials.
- Write two or three words for every strength before checking any reference.
- Mark the strength at which each material first smells most "usable" in a perfume.
- Repeat one ladder the next day and compare your words.
You have done this well if your table shows a change in character, not only in strength, for at least two materials, and you can say which dilution you would choose to evaluate each one.
Common mistakes
- Smelling strongest first. It tires the nose for the faint samples.
- Only describing strength. "Weaker" is not a character.
- Reading the table first. It steers your descriptions.
Safety
- Indole and phenylacetic acid are potent and their odor lingers; work in a ventilated space, on strips only, and read each SDS first.
Key terms
- Character shift
- A change in what a material smells like, not only how strong it is, as its concentration changes.
Knowledge check
Written and reviewed by the RUŌOD Lab team. This is general education, not legal, regulatory, medical or safety advice. Example dilutions and exercises are for learning, are not validated products, and have not been safety-assessed. Completing a lesson confers no qualification. How we check these lessons.