Raw materials & records

Flavor Grade vs Fragrance Grade: What the Label Means

What flavor-grade and fragrance-grade aroma chemicals are documented for, why food-safe is not skin-safe, and how "natural" differs between the two.

Listen to Article

Ready

Short answer

"Flavor grade" and "fragrance grade" describe what a material was made and documented for, not simply how pure it is. A flavor-grade aroma chemical is produced and certified for use in food, under food law, with specifications and impurity limits that food regulators and flavor-industry bodies require. A fragrance-grade material is made for perfumery and cosmetics, judged by odour, specification and the IFRA Standards. The same molecule can be sold in both grades; the grades are not interchangeable in either direction without checking the paperwork.

What makes a material flavor grade

A flavoring substance is something people will eat, so its rules come from food law:

  • Permitted lists. In the EU, Regulation (EC) No 1334/2008 governs flavorings, and only flavoring substances on the Union list may be used in food. In the United States, many flavor ingredients are used on the basis of "generally recognized as safe" (GRAS) determinations; the Flavor and Extract Manufacturers Association (FEMA) runs a long-standing GRAS program for flavor ingredients.
  • Specifications for food. Purity, identity tests, and limits on impurities such as heavy metals and residual solvents follow food-chemical specifications.
  • Manufacturing controls. Production, handling and storage are expected to meet food-safety requirements, and the supplier documents them.

What makes a material fragrance grade

A fragrance material goes on skin, fabric or into the air, so the questions are different:

  • Odour quality first. Perfumers specify a material by how it smells as well as by its analytical data; a trace impurity that changes the odour matters more than one that does not.
  • IFRA Standards. Restrictions, prohibitions and specifications for fragrance use; see IFRA standards explained.
  • Cosmetic and chemical law. Allergen labelling, hazard classification and the safety assessment of the finished product.

The documents that come with a fragrance material — SDS, specification, certificate of analysis, IFRA certificate — are described in fragrance material SDS and specifications.

Is flavor grade "better"?

Not for perfumery as such. A flavor-grade material is certified for a purpose a perfumer does not need, and it often costs more for that reason. Three points are worth knowing:

  1. Purity is not the same as odour. A food-grade material may meet a higher assay and still smell different from the fragrance grade a perfumer is used to, because the impurities that remain, or that were removed, differ.
  2. "Edible" is not "safe on skin". Food safety assessments look at swallowing; skin sensitisation and phototoxicity are separate questions. Cinnamaldehyde, for example, is widely used in flavors and is restricted in fragrance because of skin sensitisation. IFRA applies to a fragrance use whatever grade you bought.
  3. The reverse is the real risk. A fragrance-grade material must not go into anything eaten, drunk or put in the mouth. Lip products, toothpaste and mouthwash sit between the two worlds and have their own rules; use materials documented for that use.

Natural: two different definitions

Natural claims differ between flavors and fragrances. Under EU flavoring law a "natural flavouring substance" must be obtained from material of vegetable, animal or microbiological origin by physical, enzymatic or microbiological processes, and the regulation sets separate conditions for using the word "natural" on a label. Fragrance has no equivalent single legal definition; brands use standards such as ISO 9235 for natural aromatic raw materials and their own claims policies. A "natural" vanillin bought for flavor and a "natural" vanillin in a perfume may therefore have met different tests. See natural perfume claims and, for vanillin in particular, vanillin in perfumery.

When a perfumer meets flavor-grade materials

  • Small packs. Some retailers sell flavor-grade materials in small sizes that are convenient for a home lab. They are fine for perfumery if you ask for the IFRA certificate and treat them like any fragrance material.
  • Gourmand work. Ethyl maltol, vanillin, furaneol and the lactones are flavor classics; a perfumer may buy them from flavor suppliers. See ethyl maltol in perfumery.
  • Oral-care products. Here the flavor side's documentation is required, and fragrance-only materials are out.

What to record

Record the grade with the material: supplier, product code, grade and the purpose it is documented for. A future batch made from a different grade is a change that should be checked like any supplier change; see raw material supplier changes. Material records are the subject of the guide to perfume raw material documentation.

Sources

  • Regulation (EC) No 1334/2008 on flavourings — EUR-Lex (definitions in Article 3; the use of "natural" in Article 16).
  • U.S. food labelling of flavors, 21 CFR 101.22 — eCFR.
  • IFRA — IFRA Standards.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use a flavor-grade material in perfume?

Yes, if you have its documents and apply the IFRA Standards as you would to any fragrance material.

Can I use a fragrance-grade material in a lip balm flavor?

No. Use materials documented for that oral or lip use.

Why does the flavor grade smell different?

The impurities and the specification differ, and small impurities often carry odour.

Written and reviewed by the RUŌOD Lab team. This article is general education about perfume formulation and record-keeping; it is not legal, regulatory or safety advice, and the examples are illustrations, not validated commercial formulas. How we write and check these guides.

Formulate with the arithmetic done for you

RUŌOD Lab's material library holds supplier, cost, stock, IFRA limit, families and your own fields.