Raw materials & records

Why Natural Materials Vary from Harvest to Harvest

Plant, season, harvest and distillation change a natural from lot to lot. What that does to a formula and its compliance, and how a lab handles each new lot.

Listen to Article

Ready

Short answer

Natural raw materials vary from harvest to harvest because the plant, the weather, the time of picking and the way the material is processed all change the chemistry of what ends up in the drum. Two lots of the same essential oil from the same supplier can differ noticeably in odour, colour and the proportions of their main constituents. For a perfumer the consequence is practical: a formula built on one lot of a natural may smell different when it is made again with the next, and a working lab needs a way to notice and handle that.

Where the variation comes from

The plant

Plants of one species do not all make the same molecules in the same amounts. Some species exist as distinct chemical types — a subject of its own, covered in essential oil chemotypes — and even within one type, cultivar, age of the planting and growing region shift the balance.

The season

Sun, rainfall and temperature during the growing season affect how much oil a plant makes and its composition. A wet year, a heatwave or an early frost can all show up in the oil. This is why some suppliers describe naturals by crop year, much as wine is described by vintage.

The harvest

Flowers picked early in the morning, when many are richest in scent, differ from flowers picked later; leaves cut before and after flowering differ; roots dried for different lengths of time give different oils. The timing is a decision made by the grower, often under pressure from weather and labour.

The processing

Distillation time, steam pressure, the age of the still, whether the material was fresh or dried, and how the oil was stored afterwards all leave their mark. A long distillation draws out heavier molecules; a short one gives a lighter, fresher oil. Extraction solvents and washing steps change absolutes in the same way. Storage after production matters too: oxidation changes citrus and conifer oils quickly; see fragrance raw material shelf life.

What it does to a formula

In a formula with a natural at a few per cent, a small change in that natural may pass unnoticed. Where a natural carries the character — a rose absolute in a rose soliflore, vetiver in a vetiver perfume — the next lot can move the whole perfume. Variation also reaches compliance: the amount of a regulated constituent, such as an allergen or a phototoxic compound, follows the lot, so a calculation done on the old certificate may no longer hold for the new one. How natural constituents enter allergen and IFRA calculations is covered in fragrance allergens and how to check IFRA limits.

How suppliers manage it

  • Specifications. A supplier's specification gives ranges — density, refractive index, optical rotation, and often the percentage of key constituents by gas chromatography. A lot outside the ranges should not be shipped as that grade. Many essential oils also have ISO standards that define such ranges.
  • Blending lots. Large suppliers often blend lots from several harvests or growers to keep a product consistent from year to year. That is a service, and part of what a higher price can buy.
  • Certificates. A certificate of analysis for each lot reports what was measured on that lot. See SDS and specifications.

How a lab handles it

  1. Keep a reference sample of each lot you approve, labelled with the lot number, sealed and stored cold and dark. When the next lot arrives, compare the two on strips side by side.
  2. Check the documents against the specification and the previous certificate, as described in incoming raw material checks.
  3. Re-smell the formula that depends most on the material, made with the new lot, beside a retained sample of the last batch.
  4. Adjust openly. If the new lot is stronger or weaker, a small change in its quantity may restore the balance. Record it as a new version with the lot noted, never as a silent edit; see formula change control.
  5. Recheck compliance with the new lot's constituents.

Lot numbers belong on every batch record; batch numbers and lot codes covers the system. Supplier changes are a bigger version of the same problem and have their own page, raw material supplier changes.

When variation is a reason to choose a synthetic

Some formulators replace part of a natural with its main isolates or with a reconstituted base, so that only part of the character depends on the harvest. That is a trade: consistency for some of the depth the natural brings. The choice between them is discussed in natural vs synthetic fragrance materials. Variation is part of working with naturals, and the guide to raw material documentation is where the records that tame it begin.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Is a variable natural a bad material?

No. Variation is normal; a lot outside the specification is the problem.

Should I buy a year's supply at once?

It removes lot changes for a year but raises the risk of oxidation. Store it well and weigh that against how quickly the material ages.

Does variation affect synthetics too?

Less, but grade, purity and isomer ratio can differ between suppliers; check those when you change source.

Written and reviewed by the RUŌOD Lab team. This article is general education about perfume formulation and record-keeping; it is not legal, regulatory or safety advice, and the examples are illustrations, not validated commercial formulas. How we write and check these guides.

Formulate with the arithmetic done for you

RUŌOD Lab's material library holds supplier, cost, stock, IFRA limit, families and your own fields.