Formulation fundamentals

The Jean Carles Method: Learning Perfumery by Contrast

How Jean Carles taught perfumery at the Roure school: learn materials by comparison, build two-material accords, compose from the base up, and what still holds.

Listen to Article

Ready

Short answer

The Jean Carles method is a way of learning perfumery by comparison: you study materials side by side until you can tell similar ones apart, then you build simple accords of two materials at changing ratios, and you compose from the base upward rather than from the top down. It was set out by Jean Carles, the perfumer who founded and first directed the Roure perfumery school in Grasse in 1946, and it still shapes how many schools and self-taught perfumers organise their first years.

Who Jean Carles was

Carles (1892–1966) worked for the Grasse materials house Roure and trained its perfumers. The school he led opened formally in 1946, though he had been guiding young perfumers for years before that. He wrote his teaching down as a series of articles, usually translated as A Method of Creation in Perfumery, published in the trade press in the early 1960s; accounts disagree on the exact year and issue, so treat any date more precise than that with care. Most perfumery histories also tell that he lost much of his sense of smell late in life and kept composing from memory and knowledge of the materials — a story that makes the point of his method better than any summary: a perfumer who truly knows a palette can work with it in the head.

Step one: learn materials in groups, not one by one

The first idea is that a material is only understood in relation to others. Smelling a single strip of linalool tells you little; smelling it beside linalyl acetate, lavender oil and bergamot oil tells you what is particular to each. Carles's students worked through the palette in small groups of related materials, comparing strips at the same dilution and at intervals as they dried, until the differences became obvious and nameable.

  • Similar pairs — two roses, two vetivers, two musks — train fine discrimination.
  • Contrasting pairs — a sharp citrus beside a heavy balsam — train the sense of how far apart materials sit.
  • Repetition fixes the memory: the same group is smelled again days later, blind if possible.

The practical form of this is described in how to learn perfume materials, and keeping the palette arranged so comparisons are easy is the job of a perfume organ.

Step two: accords of two materials, at changing ratios

Once materials are known, the next exercise is to combine them two at a time. You choose a pair, blend them at a series of ratios — for example 9:1, 7:3, 1:1, 3:7, 1:9 — and smell each blend on a strip. Somewhere in the series the two stop reading as two materials and read as one new impression: that is the accord. The exercise teaches what a material contributes in a mixture, how small a quantity can change a blend, and that the right ratio is found by smelling, not by calculation. The general idea of an accord is covered in fragrance accords explained.

Adding a third material to a finished two-material accord, and then a fourth, extends the same discipline: every addition is judged against the accord as it stood before.

Step three: build the base first

The step that most surprises modern students is the order. Carles taught composing from the base upward: settle the slow, heavy materials that will carry the perfume for hours, then build the heart onto them, and add the top notes last. His reasoning was that the base is the foundation — it decides how long the perfume lasts and what character remains on skin — and a brilliant top note placed on a weak base produces a perfume that is exciting for ten minutes and then disappears. The roles of the three stages are covered in top, middle and base notes and the materials that hold a base together in perfume fixatives explained.

What still holds, and what has changed

The comparison principle holds completely. No modern training has found a better way to learn a palette than smelling related materials side by side, at the same dilution, repeatedly. The two-material accord exercise is still taught almost everywhere in some form.

Three things have changed since the method was written:

  • The palette. Carles taught with the materials of his time. Today's students meet captive molecules, woody ambers and transparent musks that blur his clear base-heart-top categories; a material such as Iso E Super is used across all three.
  • Briefs. Commercial work usually starts from a brief and often from the opening impression a client asked for, so working top-down is common in practice. Base-first remains a sound way to learn, even where it is not how every project runs.
  • Records. The method assumes notebooks. A modern student can keep each ratio series and each accord as a versioned formula; see perfume formula version control.

Using the method today

  1. Dilute your first twenty materials to the same strength, usually 10%, and label them clearly.
  2. Group them in fours by family and compare each group on strips at 1 minute, 1 hour and the next day.
  3. Pick five pairs and make a five-step ratio series for each; record which ratio reads as an accord and why.
  4. Build one small base accord, then a heart on top of it, then a top — and compare it with a version built in the opposite order.

Each step fits inside the wider process described in the perfume formulation guide. The RUŌOD Journal describes what a working perfumer does day to day, for readers rather than students, in what does a perfumer do.

Sources

  • Jean Carles, A Method of Creation in Perfumery, a series of articles in the trade journal Soap, Perfumery & Cosmetics (early 1960s; dates vary between accounts).
  • Histories of the Roure school in Grasse (founded 1946, Carles its first director), as summarised in standard reference works on twentieth-century perfumers.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Carles method only for beginners?

Its exercises are introductory, but the comparison habit is what experienced perfumers keep using when a new material arrives.

Do I have to compose from the base up?

No. It is a strong way to learn because it forces you to secure longevity first; many working perfumers start elsewhere once they know their palette.

How many materials should I start with?

Few enough to learn well — twenty to thirty is typical — so that each can be compared with its neighbours many times.

Written and reviewed by the RUŌOD Lab team. This article is general education about perfume formulation and record-keeping; it is not legal, regulatory or safety advice, and the examples are illustrations, not validated commercial formulas. How we write and check these guides.

Formulate with the arithmetic done for you

RUŌOD Lab keeps every formula as entries of weight and dilution, with status, tags and a lock.